Ground risk: what bidders do when the surveys are missing
In 6 of the 8 live tenders we read this autumn, the contractor carried ground or asbestos risk without the surveys it depends on. Bidders notice, and price it.
By J M Bryant, Founder. November 2026. 4-minute read.
The most common problem in the CALON Tender Risk Index 2026 was not a drafting slip. In 6 of the 8 live public tenders we read, the contract placed ground, structural or asbestos risk on the contractor, but the surveys that risk depends on were missing, incomplete or listed and not issued.
It is an easy gap to leave. Surveys take time, the programme is tight, and moving risk to the contractor looks like protection. It rarely is.
How a bidder reads it
An experienced bid team asks two questions: who carries the risk, and what information is there to price it with.
Under NEC4, a contractor is usually protected from unforeseeable physical conditions as a compensation event (clause 60.1(12)). It is judged against the Site Information, publicly available information referred to in it, what can be seen on a site visit, and what an experienced contractor could reasonably be expected to know (clause 60.2). If the Site Information is ambiguous or inconsistent, the contractor is assumed to have allowed for the more favourable condition (clause 60.3).
So thin Site Information under the standard clauses leaves the risk largely with the client. A Z clause that deletes or narrows 60.1(12) moves it to the contractor, and the bidder now has to price ground they cannot see.
JCT forms generally leave unforeseen ground conditions with the contractor unless the contract says otherwise. That makes the information issued with the tender even more important, because it is all the bidder has to price against.
What bidders actually do
When the risk is theirs and the information is missing, bidders choose between four responses, and the client pays for each one:
- Add a risk allowance. Every bidder prices the unknown differently, so the bids stop being comparable.
- Qualify the bid. "Price excludes contaminated ground" turns a lump sum into an estimate.
- Price low and claim later. If the risk transfer is unclear, the bidder relies on arguing it after award.
- Decline to bid. The best-informed contractors are often the first to walk away.
Asbestos is different
For refurbishment and demolition work, the client is required to provide pre-construction information under CDM 2015, and the asbestos survey is a large part of that. A refurbishment and demolition survey is normally needed before work disturbs the fabric of the building. A management survey alone is not enough. When it is missing, the bidder cannot price removal, programme or method, and the gap often becomes a delay as well as a cost.
What to check before issue
- List the surveys the scheme needs (ground investigation, contamination, structural, asbestos, utilities and services) and confirm each is issued with the tender pack, not just listed.
- Check the risk allocation matches the information. If the contractor carries ground risk, it needs the information to price it. If the information is thin, consider keeping the risk, or setting a defined reference condition.
- Read the Z clauses against the Site Information. An amendment that deletes 60.1(12) should never sit beside a missing ground investigation report.
- Use a provisional sum or a defined risk allowance where uncertainty cannot be removed before tender, so every bidder prices the same thing.
- Make the Site Information consistent. Under NEC4, ambiguity is read in the contractor's favour.
- Plan surveys into the programme. The cheapest time to commission a survey is before the tender, not after the first compensation event.
The point
Moving ground risk to the contractor without the information to price it does not remove the risk. It turns it into a premium, a qualification or a claim. A complete set of surveys, issued with the tender pack and matched to a clear allocation, is one of the cheapest ways to get prices that hold.
Commercial observations like these are not legal advice. Where an amendment needs legal interpretation, take it to your legal adviser before issue.
Sources: NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract, clauses 60.1(12), 60.2 and 60.3. Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015: client duties on pre-construction information. HSE guidance HSG264, Asbestos: The survey guide. CALON Tender Risk Index 2026.