Sample report. Fictional project, illustrative findings.
Riverside Depot drainage and resurfacing
Tender Documentation Review. NEC4 ECC Option A. Estimated value £3.2m. This is the format you receive: a rating, a decision, the conditions to close and every finding with its source and fix.
Close and verify the listed conditions before issuing the tender. We confirm each one in writing in the free close-out check.
What Level 2 of 5 means
- Level 1. AbsentNo meaningful provision. The issue has not been addressed.Hold
- Level 2. EmergingPartly addressed, inconsistent across documents. Below the pass mark.Proceed with conditions
- Level 3. EstablishedDefined and adequate for the market. The pass mark.Proceed
- Level 4. ManagedControlled, consistent and evidenced across the set.Proceed
- Level 5. RobustEmbedded and resilient to how bidders will read it.Proceed
- What sets the level: The open High findings. Any Level 1 issue means hold; anything below Level 3 comes with conditions.
- What moves this tender pack to Level 3: Closing the 4 conditions below. We check the changes and confirm in writing, at no extra charge.
- Who decides: The rating and decision are CALON's recommendation. Approval to issue stays with you.
Summary
The tender pack is close to ready, but 4 high-severity findings would each let a bidder leave cost out of the price and recover it after award. Three of the four sit where two documents disagree. None needs redesign; all can be closed by drafting before issue.
Findings log
Open any finding to see its source, how a bidder would use it and the fix.
Showing 8 of 8 findings
F01The drawings and the specification ask for different pipesDrawing C-104 and Specification 5.3High
- Finding
- Drawing C-104 shows a 450 mm concrete surface water sewer. Specification clause 5.3 calls for 300 mm twin-wall plastic pipe.
- How a bidder uses it
- Price the cheaper plastic pipe, then claim the difference as a change when the drawing is enforced.
- Exposure to the client
- Pipe, fittings and programme difference across 1.2 km of sewer.
- Fix before issue
- Correct the drawing or the specification so they agree. NEC4 has no order of precedence, and a change that resolves the conflict is assessed in the Contractor's favour.
- Owner
- Design lead
F02The ground investigation report is referred to but not issuedSite Information, section 2High
- Finding
- Site Information refers to a 2024 ground investigation report. The report is not in the tender pack.
- How a bidder uses it
- Price benign ground, then notify physical conditions under clause 60.1(12) when rock or water is found.
- Exposure to the client
- Open-ended ground risk sitting with the Client.
- Fix before issue
- Issue the ground investigation report, or remove the reference and say what is known.
- Owner
- Project manager
F03The handover date has no teeth in the contractContract Data part one and Option X7High
- Finding
- The depot handover date is mentioned only in the Scope. The completion date in Contract Data is later, and delay damages are entered as £0 per day.
- How a bidder uses it
- Finishing late costs nothing, so the handover date gets no priority over cheaper sequencing.
- Exposure to the client
- No contractual remedy if the handover date is missed.
- Fix before issue
- Make the handover date a Completion Date for a section (Option X5) with a realistic delay damages rate, or a Key Date with a stated Condition.
- Owner
- Commercial lead
F04A Z clause leaves the contractor carrying a consent delay it cannot controlZ clause Z3 and Scope 6.2Medium
- Finding
- Z3 makes the Contractor responsible for any delay in a third-party land consent. Scope 6.2 says work cannot start on that land until the consent is granted.
- How a bidder uses it
- The consent delay becomes uncompensated Contractor risk, so bidders add a premium or qualify the bid.
- Exposure to the client
- Risk premium in every price, or qualified bids that are hard to compare.
- Fix before issue
- Keep the consent risk with the Client, or add a compensation event if the consent is not granted by a stated date.
- Owner
- Commercial lead
F05A required cost is missing from the price listActivity schedule and Scope 4.4High
- Finding
- Scope 4.4 requires full traffic management for the works. The activity schedule has no traffic management activity.
- How a bidder uses it
- Leave traffic management out of the price and recover it later as a change to the Scope.
- Exposure to the client
- A significant unpriced cost on a road-based scheme.
- Fix before issue
- Add a traffic management activity and check every Scope section has a priced home.
- Owner
- Cost manager
F06Quality scores have no descriptors, so marks are hard to defendITT evaluation, quality questions Q2 to Q5Medium
- Finding
- Quality is weighted at 60%. Answers are scored 0, 5 or 10 with no descriptors for each score.
- How a bidder uses it
- Write to the question, not the project. A losing bidder has grounds to challenge inconsistent marking.
- Exposure to the client
- Award challenge and a weak link between score and delivery.
- Fix before issue
- Publish score descriptors and tie each question to a project-specific risk.
- Owner
- Procurement lead
F07The clarification deadline differs between the ITT and the portalITT section 4 and portal noticeLow
- Finding
- The ITT sets the clarification deadline 10 days before return. The portal notice says 5 days.
- How a bidder uses it
- Raise late clarifications and argue the timetable was unclear.
- Exposure to the client
- Late addenda and a possible extension to the return date.
- Fix before issue
- Align the deadline across the ITT and the portal before issue.
- Owner
- Procurement lead
F08The Form of Tender and pricing schedule treat VAT differentlyForm of Tender and pricing scheduleMedium
- Finding
- The Form of Tender asks for prices excluding VAT. The pricing schedule totals include VAT.
- How a bidder uses it
- Submit on whichever basis looks cheaper; the evaluation team then has to normalise prices.
- Exposure to the client
- Bids that cannot be compared directly, and clarification risk at evaluation.
- Fix before issue
- State one VAT basis in both documents.
- Owner
- Procurement lead
This sample uses a fictional project and fictional findings to show the format of a CALON report. It does not describe any real client, tender or document. Download the PDF version.
See this for your own tender
Send us the tender pack before bidders see it. The free sample review covers the most serious issues, each with its fix.