CALONCALON
Tender Risk Index 2026. Version 1.0, published 20 November 2026.

What a bidder would find in live public tenders

In autumn 2026 we analysed 8 live UK public-sector tender packs, 3 on NEC and 5 on JCT, from their published documents, the way an experienced bidder would. These are findings from the tender packs we reviewed, not a measure of every UK tender. No buyer, project or place is named.

Tender packs: 6 full reviews, 2 shorter triage reviews
8
Issues found
149
Per full review, on average (139 issues across 6 tender packs)
23
High severity
51

Severity of all 149 issues

High: likely to cost money or time if left in the tender pack. Medium: likely to cause clarification, qualification or dispute. Low: administrative.

High51 (34%)
Medium63 (42%)
Low35 (23%)

Where the 90 categorised issues sit

90 of the 149 issues are categorised so far. The other 59 are logged with their severity but not yet categorised, so these shares may change in the next edition. Percentages are rounded.

Contract31 (34%)
Pricing and evaluation25 (28%)
Scope23 (26%)
Procurement administration11 (12%)

Six issues we found again and again

Each appeared in at least half of the tender packs. None needs bad faith on anyone's side, and each is cheap to fix before issue.

  1. 6 of 8

    Ground, structural or asbestos risk sits with the contractor, but the surveys it depends on are missing or incomplete.

  2. 5 of 8

    The published price-scoring method conflicts with the pricing workbook, or the workbook leaves priced items out of the evaluated total.

  3. 5 of 8

    The return date, clarification deadline or timetable is stated differently across the documents and the portal.

  4. 5 of 8

    Documents listed in the tender, or needed for pricing, were not issued with the tender pack.

  5. 4 of 8

    Key Contract Data entries were left blank or marked to be confirmed: dates, contract period, damages or values.

  6. 4 of 8

    The contractor takes design responsibility for design produced by others, or has design duties with no contractual mechanism behind them.

Method and limits

How the figures were produced, and what they can and cannot tell you.

Tender packs8 live tenders, published on UK public portals in September and October 2026, chosen to cover health, higher education, housing, local government, central government and framework work.
Contract forms3 on NEC (NEC4 ECC twice, NEC3 ECSC once) and 5 on JCT forms. The recurring patterns appear on both, so they are not specific to one form.
How each tender pack was readFrom its published documents, the way an experienced bidder would. Full reviews covered every document in the tender pack; triage reviews read the tender pack for its most serious issues only. Each issue was logged with its document, clause and severity, and checked against the portal record.
Depth6 tender packs had a full review. 2 had a shorter triage review of the most serious issues only (5 each), so their totals are not comparable with the others.
SeverityHigh: likely to cost money or time if left in the tender pack.Medium: likely to cause clarification, qualification or dispute.Low: administrative.
CountingTwo issues later resolved by the buyer through clarification remain counted, because they were in the tender pack as issued.
Categories90 of 149 issues are categorised into scope, contract, pricing and evaluation, and procurement administration. The rest will be categorised in the next edition.
Limits8 tender packs is a small sample and is not representative of all UK public procurement. The findings are issues identified in documents, not proven financial loss.
Follow-upEvery review was unprompted and free. Seven buyers were sent their findings; the eighth tender had closed before they were ready. One buyer amended its evaluation scoring as a result.
Version1.0, published 20 November 2026. Corrections and later editions will be dated here.

Use these figures

You are welcome to quote this page with credit to "CALON Tender Risk Index 2026", describing the figures as findings from the 8 tender packs reviewed. The next edition will add more tender packs and a full category breakdown.

Download the one-page summary (PDF)

What would a bidder find in your tender pack?

Send us your next tender. The free sample review shows its most serious issues, each with its fix, before you commit to a fee.

Get a quoteFree sample
Ask an NEC or JCT question