Quality scoring that bidders can game
A heavy quality weighting only helps if the scoring rewards the behaviour you want. Vague questions and missing descriptors reward good bid writers instead.
By J M Bryant, Founder. November 2026. 4-minute read.
Clients often raise the quality weighting to avoid simply buying the cheapest bid. It is a sound instinct. But a high weighting magnifies whatever the quality questions actually measure, and in many tender packs that is bid-writing skill rather than delivery capability.
The patterns bidders look for
Generic questions. A question such as "describe your approach to health and safety" can be answered from a library. Every competent bidder scores well, so quality stops separating them and price decides after all.
Missing score descriptors. Where answers are scored 0, 5 or 10 with no description of what earns each mark, two evaluators can score the same answer differently. That inconsistency is the starting point for a challenge from a losing bidder.
Questions disconnected from the risks. If the project's real risks are a live railway interface or a tight school-holiday window, but no question asks about them, the evaluation cannot tell you who will manage them.
Thresholds that do not bite. A minimum score is only useful if it is set where a weak answer genuinely fails.
Why it matters more now
Under the Procurement Act 2023, contracting authorities must give each bidder an assessment summary explaining how its tender was scored against the award criteria. Scoring that cannot be explained clearly, question by question, is harder to defend.
What to check before issue
- Tie each quality question to a specific, named project risk.
- Publish descriptors for every score, written so two evaluators would reach the same mark.
- Check that the weighting between questions reflects where the project's risk actually sits.
- Test the model: would the bid you would least like to receive still score well?
The last test is the one a bid team runs on your documents. It is worth running first.