The structured method behind every CALON review, finding and rating.
The CALON Assurance Framework
One service, one lens, five maturity levels, one decision. The same structure on every engagement, so a rating means the same thing on every project and stands up when someone asks how you reached it.
You commission the review for the stage your project has reached. Each one stands alone.
Each service is scored on its own lens only. That keeps the scope tight and the fee fixed.
Absent, Emerging, Established, Managed, Robust. Level 3 is the pass mark.
Four lenses. Five levels. One pass mark
Each lens is scored from Level 1, Absent, to Level 5, Robust. The line is Level 3: below it, a finding is recorded as a gap, not smoothed over. Illustrative scorecard for a project reviewed at all four stages.
| Lens | Maturity level | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Case and fundingBusiness case stage | Level 3. Established | Proceed |
| Route and risk allocationStrategy stage | Level 4. Managed | Proceed |
| Buildability and costDesign stage | Level 2. Emerging | Proceed with conditions |
| Scope and contractTender stage | Level 3. Established | Proceed |
How a score becomes a call
Any Level 1 is reported as a hold, whatever the rest of the review shows. Anything below Level 3 comes with conditions that must be closed before issue.
| Level | What it means | Typical decision |
|---|---|---|
| Level 1Absent | No meaningful provision. The issue has not been addressed. | Hold |
| Level 2Emerging | Partly addressed, inconsistent across documents. Below the pass mark. | Proceed with conditions |
| Level 3Established | Defined and adequate for the market. The pass mark. | Proceed |
| Level 4Managed | Controlled, consistent and evidenced across the set. | Proceed |
| Level 5Robust | Embedded and resilient to how bidders will read it. | Proceed |
Five rules on every engagement
- Independent
- No interest in the outcome or the award.
- Proportionate
- Depth matched to value and risk.
- Evidence-led
- Every finding cites its source.
- Before commitment
- Always before a contractor is appointed.
- Decision-focused
- Ends in a call you can act on.
Put the framework to work on your project
Tell us which review you need, or describe the project and we will recommend one. A fixed-fee proposal follows within two working days.