CALONCALON
From the CALON LinkedIn series, January 2027.

NEC4: who's right?

Fifteen everyday NEC4 ECC disputes. Each went out as a LinkedIn poll. The full answer, with the clause and a pre-tender check, unlocks here at 08:00 the morning after.

General information on the published NEC4 ECC, not legal advice. Z clauses and Contract Data entries can change any of these answers.

Day 1 of 15 Wed 6 Jan 2027

Programme acceptance

The Contractor submits its first programme for acceptance. Two weeks pass with no reply from the Project Manager. The Contractor notifies that failure. Another week goes by. Still nothing.

  • The Contractor says: that programme is now accepted.
  • The Project Manager says: I never accepted it. Silence is not acceptance.
Unlocks Thu 7 Jan at 08:00

Day 2 of 15 Thu 7 Jan 2027

Missed early warning

From week 2 the Contractor knows the utility company's diversion is running late, but gives no early warning. In week 10 the utility company works later than the Accepted Programme shows and the job is delayed. It is a compensation event. When instructing a quotation, the Project Manager states that an experienced contractor could have given an early warning.

  • The Contractor says: it is a compensation event, so we are paid in full.
  • The Project Manager says: you stayed silent, so you get nothing.
Unlocks Fri 8 Jan at 08:00

Day 3 of 15 Fri 8 Jan 2027

Work missing from the activity schedule

Option A. The Scope requires temporary fencing around the site compound for the whole job. The Contractor's activity schedule has no fencing activity.

  • The Contractor says: we never priced it, so fencing is extra and should be a compensation event.
  • The Client says: it is in the Scope, so it is in your Prices.
Unlocks Mon 11 Jan at 08:00

Day 4 of 15 Mon 11 Jan 2027

Eight-week time bar

In week 5 the Project Manager instructs an extra drainage run, a change to the Scope, but does not notify it as a compensation event. In week 15 the Contractor notifies it. That is ten weeks later.

  • The Project Manager says: out of time. The eight-week bar applies, so nothing changes.
  • The Contractor says: the bar does not apply to this one.
Unlocks Tue 12 Jan at 08:00

Day 5 of 15 Tue 12 Jan 2027

Access dates

Contract Data part one gives an access date in week 4. The Accepted Programme shows the Contractor needing access in week 6. The Client gives access in week 5.

  • The Contractor says: the access date was week 4. One week late, so it is a compensation event.
  • The Client says: we gave access before you planned to need it.
Unlocks Wed 13 Jan at 08:00

Day 6 of 15 Wed 13 Jan 2027

Project Manager ignores a notification

The Contractor notifies an event it believes is a compensation event. A week passes with no reply from the Project Manager. The Contractor notifies that failure. Two more weeks pass. Still no reply.

  • The Contractor says: it is now a compensation event, and we are instructed to quote.
  • The Project Manager says: I am still considering it. Nothing is agreed until I decide.
Unlocks Thu 14 Jan at 08:00

Day 7 of 15 Thu 14 Jan 2027

Weather

February is the wettest the site manager has known. At the weather station named in the Contract Data, February's rainfall is above the one in five year level but below the one in ten year level. The Completion Date is in May.

  • The Contractor says: exceptional weather. Compensation event.
  • The Project Manager says: not exceptional enough.
Unlocks Fri 15 Jan at 08:00

Day 8 of 15 Fri 15 Jan 2027

Subcontractor's delay

The Project Manager accepted the Contractor's groundworks subcontractor. The subcontractor's poor work then delays the job by three weeks.

  • The Contractor says: you accepted this subcontractor, so the delay is the Client's problem.
  • The Client says: your subcontractor, your problem.
Unlocks Mon 18 Jan at 08:00

Day 9 of 15 Mon 18 Jan 2027

Late reply to a quotation

The Contractor submits a quotation for a compensation event. Two weeks pass with no reply. The Contractor notifies that failure. Ten days later the Project Manager instructs a revised quotation.

  • The Contractor says: too late. Our quotation is accepted.
  • The Project Manager says: I replied in time.
Unlocks Tue 19 Jan at 08:00

Day 10 of 15 Tue 19 Jan 2027

Pay less notice

Option Y(UK)2 applies, with no different period in the Contract Data. The assessment date is the 1st, so payment is due on the 8th and the final date for payment is the 22nd. The Client issues a pay less notice on the 18th.

  • The Contractor says: that notice is too late.
  • The Client says: it is before the final date, so it counts.
Unlocks Wed 20 Jan at 08:00

Day 11 of 15 Wed 20 Jan 2027

Accepted design fails

The Contractor designs a retaining wall. The Project Manager accepts the design. Six months later the wall cracks because of a design error.

  • The Contractor says: the Project Manager accepted the design, so it is now the Client's risk.
  • The Client says: you designed it, you own it.
Unlocks Thu 21 Jan at 08:00

Day 12 of 15 Thu 21 Jan 2027

Delay damages after a later Completion Date

Option X7 applies. The Contractor finishes four weeks late and the Client takes four weeks of delay damages. Two months later a compensation event is implemented that moves the Completion Date three weeks later.

  • The Contractor says: repay three weeks of damages, with interest.
  • The Client says: the damages were right when we took them.
Unlocks Fri 22 Jan at 08:00

Day 13 of 15 Fri 22 Jan 2027

Whole life cost proposal

Option X21 applies. The Contractor proposes a different pump set that would cut the whole life cost of the asset, with a full quotation. The Project Manager rejects it without giving a reason.

  • The Contractor says: you cannot reject a saving without a good reason, and we should share in it.
  • The Project Manager says: I can reject it, and there is no share.
Unlocks Mon 25 Jan at 08:00

Day 14 of 15 Mon 25 Jan 2027

Early use of part of the works

The new car park is finished but Completion of the whole works is still weeks away. Under pressure from staff, the Client opens the car park and starts using it.

  • The Contractor says: by using it, you have taken it over.
  • The Client says: nothing has been certified, so nothing has been taken over.
Unlocks Tue 26 Jan at 08:00

Day 15 of 15 Tue 26 Jan 2027

Rock in the trench

The Site Information includes borehole logs showing weathered rock about two metres down in places. During excavation the Contractor hits hard rock along the whole length of the trench.

  • The Contractor says: unforeseen ground. Every metre of rock excavation is a compensation event.
  • The Client says: you were told about rock. No compensation event.
Unlocks Wed 27 Jan at 08:00
Most of these arguments are decided before a contractor is appointed: in the Contract Data, the Scope and the Site Information. Send us your next tender pack and we will show you where yours would start. Get a fixed-fee quote or try a free sample review.
Get a quoteFree sample
Ask an NEC or JCT question